EDITOR NOTE: The three Congress hearings that took place simultaneously this week have separate agendas. On the public side of things, the Senate Judiciary Committee is concerned about the use of cryptocurrency in ransomware attacks, the House Financial Services Committee is exploring the use cases of the digital dollar, and the Senate Banking Committee is simply looking to explore the implications of general crypto adoption. Implicitly, the three committees may be looking to examine the threat that decentralized currencies pose to centralized government, the use of the digital dollar to further the government’s control over the American economy and its people and whether cryptos pose a competitive threat to the national currency which makes rampant fiscal spending possible. HODLer hopes for crypto adoption is an ironic overturning of the ideological principles and anarchic spirit that gave birth to the concept of a decentralized monetary system upon which cryptocurrencies were founded. Now, they’re just another tool for the government to regulate and use to its own benefit.
Congress is holding three simultaneous hearings around cryptocurrencies today – and they're all on different types of use cases.
Congress is continuing to hold hearings around the digital asset sector, with three simultaneous meetings today to discuss different uses for cryptocurrencies.
Crypto in Congress
I originally pitched this newsletter a year ago as a vehicle to discuss regulatory issues and the U.S. Congress’ approach to crypto in a more in-depth way than in a straight news article. Part of my thesis at the time was that I fully expected to see more regulatory interactions with the crypto world. Anyways, Congress is holding three (or two, depending on how you look at it) hearings that are important for crypto today. At the same time.
Why it matters
The Senate Judiciary Committee is holding a hearing on ransomware, the Senate Banking Committee is holding a hearing on crypto uses and the House Financial Services Committee is holding a hearing on central bank digital currencies. The fact we’re seeing three simultaneous hearings on different aspects of the crypto industry shows how much attention Congress is paying to this sector.
Breaking it down
Each of Congress’ hearings start at 10:00 a.m. Eastern, or about 30 minutes after this newsletter is emailed out. CoinDesk will, of course, be covering all three hearings.
I’m going to take this in order of most adjacent to crypto to most direct.
The Senate Committee on the Judiciary will hold a hearing titled “America Under Cyber Siege: Preventing and Responding to Ransomware Attacks,” with a witness panel of government officials. As of my writing this, there’s no hearing memo and no pre-published witness testimony, so it’s hard to gauge just how much crypto will actually come up.
However, we know that regulators are eyeing cryptocurrencies as a payment tool for ransomware attacks, and this did come up during a House Committee on Homeland Security hearing last week. I fully expect crypto to come up again today, and it’ll be worth paying attention to government officials’ recommendations on regulating or restricting ransomware payments through crypto.
The witnesses at this hearing are:
Richard Downing, U.S. Department of Justice Deputy Assistant Attorney General, Criminal Division
Bryan Vorndran, FBI Assistant Director, Cyber Division
Eric Goldstein, Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency Executive Assistant Director
Jeremy Sheridan, U.S. Secret Service Assistant Director
Sheridan was a witness at the aforementioned House hearing, where he told lawmakers that criminals can use cryptocurrencies for a variety of illicit activities.
“The rapid expansion of cryptocurrencies, as well as other digital stores of value, presents a significant challenge to law enforcement, and a growing area of risk to the U.S. and our foreign partners,” Sheridan said in his testimony to last week’s House committee.
The rest of his testimony is worth a look but tl;dr the U.S. Secret Service has some concerns about how crypto might be used in money laundering. I imagine we’ll hear something similar in today’s hearing.
I plan to livetweet this hearing – you can follow along on Twitter @nikhileshde.
House Financial Services
The House Committee on Financial Services hearing titled “The Promises and Perils of Central Bank Digital Currencies” (CBDC) should take a different tack. A hearing memo raises a number of questions we’ve heard before, including how a CBDC might address monetary policy and financial stability concerns, national security concerns, privacy, financial crimes and cybersecurity concerns.
The witness statements likewise focus more on policy concerns around a digital dollar/U.S. CBDC than they do on arguments about whether a U.S.-issued crypto is even a good idea – in other words, so far it seems like this will be pretty substantive.
It’s important to note that this hearing will be held by the Subcommittee on National Security, International Development and Monetary Policy, the same subcommittee which held a hearing on how cryptocurrencies might be used in terrorist financing earlier this year.
The witnesses are:
Julia Coronado, MacroPolicy Perspectives President and Founder
Yaya Fanusie, Center for a New American Security Adjunct Senior Fellow
Julia Friedlander, Atlantic Council Senior Fellow and Deputy Director
Andrew Levin, Dartmouth College Professor of Economics
Robert M. Baldwin, Association for Digital Asset Markets Head of Policy
The witness list is an interesting blend of industry insiders, researchers and academics.
In pre-written testimony shared with CoinDesk ahead of the hearing, Baldwin recommended policymakers look at how a CBDC might impact the commercial payment system in addition to how it could be administered and used.
My colleague Sandali Handagama will cover this hearing. You can follow her on Twitter @iamsandali.
Last, certainly not least (and possibly most), the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs will host a hearing titled “Cryptocurrencies: What are they good for?”
It’s a loaded title, but the witness list suggests that this will also be a very substantive hearing. We’ll hear from:
Angela Walch, St. Mary’s University School of Law Professor
Jerry Brito, Coin Center Executive Director
Marta Belcher, Filecoin Foundation Chair
In other words, the three witnesses all have deep expertise within the crypto industry, whether as researchers or as participants in crypto-focused organizations.
I don’t have a whole lot on what sort of questions might be asked but, as Ron Hammond of the Blockchain Association points out, this hearing will have both crypto critics and advocates in Congress asking questions.The hearing will also take place a day before SEC Chair Gary Gensler is expected to explain his agency’s authority in regulating crypto exchanges, as well as answer a host of other questions about the industry in response to a public letter from Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.).
“I’m looking forward to discussing cryptocurrency’s use cases and the promise of decentralized technologies at the hearing. I think it’s an important dialogue to have in order to ensure that future legislation does not have unintended consequences that could chill innovation in this space,” Belcher told me via email.
My colleague Daniel Nelson will cover this hearing. You can find him on Twitter @realDannyNelson.
Yesterday, Bloomberg reported that the U.S. Department of Justice was investigating Tether on bank fraud allegations.
“Specifically, federal prosecutors are scrutinizing whether Tether concealed from banks that transactions were linked to crypto, said three people with direct knowledge of the matter who asked not to be named because the probe is confidential,” according to the report.
Tether’s banking woes aren’t exactly new: In its settlement with the company, the New York Attorney General’s office detailed some of its banking issues. Tether and Bitfinex, its sister firm with which it shares key ownership and managers, both used banks in Taiwan, with Wells Fargo acting as a correspondent bank, according to the legal filing.
Wells Fargo cut Tether off in early 2017, at which point the stablecoin issuer found a few other banks before ultimately landing with Deltec (though it’s possible this isn’t Tether’s only bank right now).
Read more at Coin Desk