EDITOR NOTE: There are A LOT OF THINGS FRIGHTENINGLY WRONG with what the Fed’s James Bullard had to say on CNBC regarding Bitcoin, Gold, and the threat to the dollar. Let’s take his statements apart. “It’s going to be a dollar economy as far as the eye can see.” Possibly, as it's America’s only circulating currency. “A dollar global economy really as far as the eye can see.” Really? That’s pretty arrogant and naive considering China and the rapid de-dollarization efforts that threaten to unseat the dollar. “Whether...gold price goes up or down, or the bitcoin price goes up or down, doesn’t really affect [the dollar].” Gold or bitcoin can’t affect or “save” the dollar from declining if it's being debased or if international investors are dumping it. Inversely, it’s because the dollar is sinking in a fluctuating manner that gold and bitcoin prices go up and down. “Dollars can be traded electronically already, so I’m not sure that’s really the issue here.” Perhaps the issue is that the Fed’s monetary policy is debasing the dollar and that our purchasing power is eroding? Bullard even had the gall to compare cryptocurrencies and gold to the pre-civil war practice of using different currencies before the dollar was officially recognized as “the” legal tender. What he failed to acknowledge is that the dollar--unlike most other currencies--was backed by gold and silver. Now, the dollar is as good as one of those rogue unbacked currencies that can easily be manipulated. If Bullard is among the “best and brightest” that the Fed has to offer in terms of policymakers, then based on his statements alone, which are, quite frankly, shockingly moronic, then we truly have a lot to worry about.
“I just think for Fed policy, it’s going to be a dollar economy as far as the eye can see — a dollar global economy really as far as the eye can see — and whether the gold price goes up or down, or the bitcoin price goes up or down, doesn’t really affect that,” Bullard said on “Squawk Box.”
Bitcoin, in particular, has been championed by crypto bulls as a store of value that can be used to hedge against inflation or the debasement of fiat currencies like the dollar. Some have touted it as “digital gold.” In addition, bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies also present themselves as a way to buy goods and services like actual money.
Bullard, who has led the St. Louis Fed since 2008, expressed concerns about widespread transactions using a range of cryptocurrencies that are not issued by governments. “Dollars can be traded electronically already, so I’m not sure that’s really the issue here. The issue is privately issued currency,” he said.
Before the Civil War, it was common for banks to issue their own notes, Bullard said. He likened it to Bank of America, JPMorgan and Wells Fargo all having distinct brands of dollars. “They were all trading around and they traded at different discounts to each other, and people did not like it at all,” he said.
“I think the same thing would occur with bitcoin here,” Bullard said. “You don’t want to go to a nonuniform currency where you’re walking into Starbucks and maybe you’ll pay with ethereum, maybe you’ll pay with ripple, maybe you’ll pay with bitcoin, maybe you’ll pay with a dollar. That isn’t how we do this. We have a uniform currency that came in at the Civil War time.”
Bullard’s comments happened shortly after the price of bitcoin eclipsed $50,000 per coin for the first time. The latest leg higher for bitcoin follows moves into the crypto space by established financial firms such as BNY Mellon and Mastercard.
Tesla also announced last week it bought $1.5 billion worth of bitcoin using cash on its balance sheet and planned to accept the digital coin as payment for its products. The electric vehicle maker’s action was viewed by some as another major step toward broad acceptance of bitcoin, which is the world’s largest digital currency by market value.
While Uber doesn’t plan to buy bitcoin as an investment, CEO Dara Khosrowshahi said it’s possible the ride hailing and food delivery company would eventually allow customers to pay with digital coins. “Just like we accept all kinds of local currency, we are going to look at cryptocurrency and/or bitcoin in terms of currency to transact,” Khosrowshahi told CNBC on Thursday. “That we’ll certainly look at and if there’s a benefit there, if there’s a need there, we’ll do it. We’re just not going to do it as part of a promotion.”
When considering whether cryptocurrencies present a threat to the dollar, Bullard stressed there’s nothing new about competition. It’s something that has gone on for centuries, he said. “It is a currency competition, and investors want a safe haven. They want a stable store of value, and then they want to conduct their investments in that currency,” the St. Louis Fed president said.
For example, he contended both the euro and the yen are strong currencies. However, “neither of those is going to replace the dollar,” he said. “It’d be very hard to get a private currency that’s really more like gold to play that role so I don’t think we’re going to see any changes in the future.”
Originally posted on CNBC